The final reports of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission and the National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women speak to ongoing work of reconciliation. Residential schools represent the tip of the iceberg., Read more: The National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls concluded in its 2019 final report that the Canadian state has perpetrated genocide against Indigenous peoples. Indigenous cultures across Canada are diverse, but there are commonalities among them. display her art, canceled the exhibit after media backlash. Parrott, Z. The use of the word Indian is considered offensive by many First Nations. Gouvernement du Canada Apprenez-en plus propos des peuples autochtones et de leurs relations avec le gouvernement fdral. After much criticism, the companys founders, Dan and Dean Caten, released an apology in 2016. This is why Indigenous Engagement isn't Stakeholder Engagement and why Indigenous Peoples get offended when referred to as Stakeholders. In 2011, only about half (49.3 per cent) of the 637,660 First Nations people in Canada who reported being Status Indianslived on a reserve. Government of CanadaLearn more about Indigenous peoples and their relationship to the federal government. Cultural appropriation is considered to be harmful for several reasons. Indigenous comes from the Latin word indigena, which means "sprung from the land; native." Therefore, using "Indigenous" over "Aboriginal" reinforces land claims and encourages territory acknowledgements, a practice which links Indigenous Peoples to their land and respects their claims over it. It is being used synonymously withAboriginal, and in many cases it is the preferred term as the collective noun forFirst Nations,Mtis, andInuit. The term Aboriginal was introduced in the 1982 Canadian Constitution by your federal government as an umbrella term to include First Nations, Inuit and Mtis. The ab in Aboriginal is a Latin prefix that means away from or not, so in that sense, Aboriginal can actually mean not original - not exactly what were trying to convey with the term. Many myths and misunderstandings dominate the public discourse, hindering informed discussion on this subject that is so important to the future of our nations. This can include using aspects of traditional knowledge or cultural expressions, as well as particular music, dances, regalia, cuisine, symbols, ceremonies,
Congress of Aboriginal PeoplesVisit the CAPs website to learn more about their organization. The Aboriginal languages of First Nations people, Mtis and Inuit: UNESCO Atlas of the Worlds Languages in Danger. "Indigenous" refers to all of these groups, either collectively or separately, and is the term used in international contexts, e.g., the 'United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples' (UNDRIP). In the 2016 Census, 11,620 people in Canada claimed Cherokee ancestry. Check here for latest versions. Traditional Indigenous education is different from European-style education. Mtis, Mikmaq and Nipmuc heritage for lacking a clear connection to any Indigenous community despite
Through the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, along with the International Labour Organizations' Indigenous and Tribal Peoples Convention 169, "Indigenous" has become the global standard in terminology. the Edmonton Eskimos (a CFL team) to change their name. Some of them have changed or are changing. By intentionally calling out the antiquated language, we hope to encourage more Canadians to consider the ways in which they think about Indigenous Peoples in this country. Culture is an expression of a communitys worldview and unique relationship with the land. As part of the change, the council said that for applicants seeking funding, it will expect some indication that authentic and respectful efforts have been made to engage with the artists or other members of
So there are limited situations where Status Indians may not have to pay income tax or sales tax. For example, don't start your meeting by saying, "Hi, we are here to talk to you because you are one of the stakeholders on our list." Universit Laval provides funding as a founding partner of The Conversation CA-FR. Potlatches are large events that can last several days. Indigenous peoples are the holders of unique languages, knowledge systems and beliefs and possess invaluable knowledge of practices for the sustainable management of natural resources. However, Superior Court Judge Thomas McEwen ruled that the team was not breaking any Canadian laws against discrimination. Through our work we are learning to incorporate Indigenous epistemologies into our actions and understandings, supporting decolonization, reconciliation, and Indigenization to advocate systemic changes in the post-secondary environment of B.C. For example, if you are on Musqueam territory, you should acknowledge the Musqueam people of the Coast Salish Nations. The term "Indigenous" is increasingly replacing the term "Aboriginal", as the former is recognized internationally, for instance with the United Nations' Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. He also filed an application with the Ontario Superior Court, hoping for an injunction requiring the team to wear another uniform during a game in Toronto and requiring the Canadian broadcaster to avoid using the name and logo. Follow us on Twitter where we share news on technology, sovereignty, business, and more. the Indigenous population will likely grow to more than 2.5 million people. These have had historic and ongoing impacts on generations of Indigenous peoples. In the 2021 census by Statistics Canada,
You may notice that the terms American Indian and Native Indian are still in current and common usage in the United States. January 11, 2023. Building Stronger Communities through Indigenous Data Sovereignty: Three Starting Points, Emphasizing a Content-Focused Approach in Your Indigenous Website Design, Truth & Reconciliation in Business in 2023, #DataBack | Recognize and Reclaim Indigenous Data Sovereignty, Pathfinding: A Different Approach to Software Development. Their homeland, known as Inuit Nunangat, includes much of the land, water and ice contained in the Arctic region. Scholar Rayna Green first described this phenomenon as playing Indian a process where the colonizers take on the supposed identity of the colonized, resulting in the promotion of stereotypes. incorporate Indigenous content into their celebrations. Crown-Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs, Economic Conditions of Indigenous Peoples. When European colonization started in 1788, it was devastating for Australia's Indigenous communities. Nevertheless, this research remains valuable both as historical and historiographical
View. The First Nations population numbered 1,048,405, the Mtis population was 624,220, and the Inuit population reached 70,545. Each Indigenous community determines who are respected Elders. In 2016, more than 1.6 million people identified as Indigenous in Canada. They often include two important aspects: the host giving away gifts, and the recording, in oral history, of the events and arrangements included in the ceremony. Our team will be reviewing your submission and get back to you with any further questions. report by Jorge Barrera for the Aboriginal Peoples Television Network in December 2016. Their numbers fell from around 750,000 to just 93,000 by 1900. Click on About Inuit for a history of the Inuit people and their contacts with Europeans. Native Hawaiians are the aboriginal, indigenous people who settled the Hawaiian archipelago, founded the Hawaiian nation, and exercised sovereignty over the Hawaiian Islands. Other early forms of appropriation, according to some Indigenous peoples, included depictions of Indians in 17th, 18th, 19th and 20th century novels, advertisements and other literature. Do Men Still Wear Button Holes At Weddings? Through the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, along with the International Labour Organizations Indigenous and Tribal Peoples Convention 169, Indigenous has become the global standard in terminology. their worldviews and livelihood throughout all segments of society. Indigenous refers to all of these groups, either collectively or separately, and is the term used in international contexts, e.g., the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP). More than anything, this is a testament to the resilience and strength of Indigenous peoples. These terms will be explained as we progress through the guide. One email per week, every Wednesday, and you can unsubscribe at any time! Native Hawaiians Are a Race of People. This term came into common usage in the 1970s and '80s and generally replaced the term "Indian," although unlike "Indian," the term "First Nation" does not have a legal definition. If you receive the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander region in your DNA results, this tells you that you probably had an ancestor who was an Indigenous Australian. For Indigenous peoples in Canada, cultural appropriation is rooted in colonization and ongoing oppression. Traditionally their societies have been communal, every member had roles and responsibilities, there was equality between men and women, nature was valued, and life was cyclical. occurs without permission or where it results in unfavourable representations, is not permissible within creative license. The consensus, however, is that whenever possible, Native people prefer to be called by their specific tribal name. Some of them have changed or are changing. Its still an umbrella term for a large group of people and it should only be used in situations where you are addressing all Indigenous groups as a collective. Sapirs geographical framework was adopted by the Smithsonian Institutions Handbook of North American Indians, the first volumes of which were published in 1978, and continues to be used widely in scholarship. Other behaviours that can constitute genocide include inflicting mental or physical harm, such as the sexual abuse and mistreatment of children in residential schools; imposing living conditions designed to result in physical destruction, such as imposed starvation to develop the Canadian West; lack of adequate food, water or medical care; imposing measures designed to prevent births, such as forced sterilization; and forcibly transferring children from the group, such as residential schools and the 60s Scoop. Our federal Constitution, our Charter of Rights and Freedoms, and our laws protect my rights as a Canadian citizen, same as you. Several national organizations in Canada are changing their names from Aboriginal to Indigenous. Most notable was the change of Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development Canada (AANDC) to Indigenous and Northern Affairs Canada (INAC) in 2015, which then split into Indigenous Services Canada and Crown-Indigenous Relations and Northern Development Canada, . According to the 2016 Census,[1] there are over 70 distinct Indigenous languages recognized across the country, and UNESCOs world atlas of languages in danger recognizes over 80 distinct Indigenous languages in Canada, including those that no longer have speakers.[2]. Treaties form the constitutional and moral basis of alliance between Indigenous peoples and
Canada. They have a special relation to and use of their traditional land. For years, laws prohibited Indigenous peoples from practicing their cultures and engaging in ceremonies. Signing up enhances your TCE experience with the ability to save items to your personal reading list, and access the interactive map. By Muriel Schmidt February 3, 2023 In Canada The term Aboriginal was introduced in the 1982 Canadian Constitution by your federal government as an 'umbrella' term to include First Nations, Inuit and Mtis. Elders play an important role in maintaining the tradition of passing along oral histories. Statistics CanadaExplore this website for more details on Indigenous demographics in Canada. They formed complex social, political, economic and cultural systems before Europeans came to North America. Here are some considerations: Genocide encompasses a variety of lethal and non-lethal acts, including acts of slow death. There are five forms of prohibited behaviour murder is only one of them. "Indian," for instance, is the generic term used in the Indian Act, a centerpiece of state identity . of cultural items by non-Indigenous peoples are considered by some Indigenous peoples to be insensitive and inauthentic. However, the term Aboriginal is still used and accepted. This genocide is the underlying cause of the contemporary murders and disappearances of Indigenous women and girls. loss of land, and declining or unequal access to food resources and public services, have had devastating consequences on the health and socio-economic well-being of
From 2016 to 2021, the Indigenous population grew 9.4 per cent. Will a DNA test show if you are Aboriginal? Cultural appropriation is the act of taking from someone elses culture without their consent. In many cases, this divides understandings of Indigenous
Among other charges, Barrera criticized Boyden who had referred to himself at various times as having Ojibwe,
Naming things for what they are is necessary. This is not free housing! the purchase of authentic crafts, clothing and works of fine art. These statutes have generally defined an Aboriginal or Indigenous person as 'a person who is a descendant of an indigenous inhabitant of Australia', or a member or a person 'of the Aboriginal race of Australia'. For their knowledge, wisdom, and behaviour, Elders are valuable role models and teachers for all members of the community. are just two examples of artists and designers who create pieces that showcase Indigenous culture in an authentic, meaningful way. Tip of the iceberg: The true state of drinking water advisories in First Nations. The Inuit primarily inhabit the northern regions of Canada. The largest First Nations populations are in Ontario, British Columbia, and Alberta. Indigenous culture has been used to promote Canadian anniversaries and events. Proponents of the collections argued that there is a deep history of the Indian mas tradition in Trinidad. A s artistic director of Native Earth Performing Arts, a theatre company dedicated to "artistic expression of the Aboriginal experience in Canada," Yvette Nolan well understands the power of. In the 2021 census by Statistics Canada , over 1.8 million people in Canada identified as Indigenous, making up 5 per cent of the national population. While exhibit organizers claimed to create authentic portrayals of Indigenous peoples and traditional ways of life, the
A Potlatch may be held to celebrate births, marriages, or deaths; settle disputes; raise totem poles; or pass on names, songs, dances, or other responsibilities. For example, Indian is now considered offensive and has been replaced by First . It is a common misconception that First Nations people in Canada do not pay federal or provincial taxes. It seems like the type of mass graves commonly found at sites where genocide took place. Prime Minister
Scholars who critiqued these depictions
The government took away cultural items used in the Potlatch, such as drums, blankets, and masks. October 11, 2019 Plus, you will never miss another Animikii article by staying connected with our News River! Non-Status Indians are Indigenous peoples who are not registered with the federal government (See also Indian). Some Inuit people take offense with this term, some do not. Some critics continue to note the importance of engaging with the traditions and teachings of other cultures as part of a creative process. a mans racial composition is never an entirely benign exercise. In January 2017, Boyden responded to critics with a statement about his mixed-blood ancestry later claiming to have DNA evidence of Native American heritage but also acknowledged that
1. Oral histories and stories have been passed down from generation to generation and are essential to maintaining Indigenous identity and culture. We cant call it Inuit History Month or Anishinabek History Month because then the celebration would only recognize these specific communities. Indigenous cultures are traditionally inclusive. Indigenous comes from the Latin word indigena, which means sprung from the land; native. Therefore, using Indigenous over Aboriginal reinforces land claims and encourages territory acknowledgements, a practice which links Indigenous Peoples to their land and respects their claims over it. First Nations make up the largest group of Indigenous Peoples in Canada. The central element of genocide is the specific intent to destroy the protected group. Working Group Guide: What is an Open Working Group? Terminology Guide Terms to Use Indigenous Indigenous" is an umbrella term for First Nations (status and non-status), Mtis and Inuit. persistence, asserted mobility and professed their political defiance against the forces of colonization. A collective noun for First Nations, Inuit Metis and growing in popularity in Canada. Various minor and major league sports teams have used Indigenous names and icons to promote their teams. Other examples include the sale of provocative and culturally insensitive Halloween costumes, such as headdresses. offensive. The roots, boughs, bark, and trunk of the red and yellow cedar are sustainably harvested and used for cultural and practical purposes. With colonization and white settlement, traditional Indigenous ways of life were forever altered. Native Hawaiians, also known as Kanaka Maoli, are the indigenous or aboriginal people (and their descendants) of the Hawaiian islands. AUF (Agence Universitaire de la Francophonie), Why many Canadians dont seem to care about the lasting effects of residential schools, Tip of the iceberg: The true state of drinking water advisories in First Nations, Sydney Horizon Fellowships (Climate Change, Health and Sustainability), Dean, School of Engineering, Design and Built Environment. The controversy over Boydens ancestry quickly spread to a wider debate about who can claim Indigenous identity, with many critics calling for Boyden to prove his Indigenous heritage, while others, like writerJonathan Kay, cautioned that an attack upon
Each of these three predecessor terms had existing functions in Canadian law. The acts of violence and intent to destroy are structural, systemic and cut across multiple administrations and political leaders. Today, there are around 630 different First Nation communities across Canada about half of which are in British Columbia and Ontario. The numbers vary widely by province, with Quebec having the highest proportion of First Nations people living on reserve, at nearly three-quarters. carrying costumes such as Reservation Royalty and Native American Princess. The display and sale of these costumes are believed to perpetuate derogatory messages about Indigenous peoples, including the sexualization of Indigenous women. For example, income earned on a reserve can be tax exempt, and any goods or services purchased by a Status Indian on a reserve or delivered to them on a reserve are sales-tax exempt. Koori is a term denoting an Aboriginal person of southern New South Wales or Victoria. as contributing and valuable members of contemporary society. For example, Canadian writer W.P. ct intro final. Which Teeth Are Normally Considered Anodontia. Thanks for contributing to The Canadian Encyclopedia. posted by the CBC in 2014, the word Aboriginal is not only an English word but also has a curious etymological backstory. may live far from their ancestral homelands, and indeed may form new communities rooted in urban centres rather than traditional lands. or from an Indigenous perspective when they are not of that culture. Then came the stunning news the remains of 215 children found on the grounds of a former residential school in Kamloops, B.C. However, we recognize that Indigenous Peoples is not a perfect term. various products. If you are an Indian Residential School survivor, or have been affected by the residential school system and need help, you can contact the 24-hour Indian Residential Schools Crisis Line: 1-866-925-4419. Third, local artisans such as basket makers end up competing with the commercialization and appropriation of their work. Indigenous peoples. For example, a masquerade
1. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people find the term offensive as it suggests that Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australia did not have a history before European invasion, because it is not written and recorded. In this way, it has been observed that cultural appropriation continues to present Indigenous peoples as a conquered group of the past, limiting understandings of Indigenous peoples
Indigenous ways of life have been threatened since contact, most notably during the residential school era. Just as one province differs from the next province, Indigenous Peoples and communities vary dramatically from coast to coast to coast in regards to culture, language, and traditions. Under certain circumstances, Status Indians can be exempted from paying tax. The terms Aboriginal, Indigenous and First Peoples are generally accepted terms in Canada and are inclusive of First Nations, Mtis and Inuit. in bikini-style costumes with feather headdresses resembling the traditional and ceremonial war bonnet of the Lakota nation prompted accusations of cultural appropriation and hypersexualization of women. Aboriginal is an oversimplification that hides more meaning than it conveys. Film and television have appropriated Indigenous culture and promoted stereotypes of Indigenous peoples. Are five forms of prohibited behaviour murder is only one of them of artists and designers who pieces! The Indian mas tradition in Trinidad people of the Indian mas tradition in.... Reviewing your submission and get back to you with any further questions in Ontario British. Remains valuable both as historical and historiographical View team ) to change their name,! Used to promote their teams the acts of violence and intent to destroy the protected group from! Special relation to and use of their traditional land a communitys worldview and unique with! Cultures across Canada are changing their names from Aboriginal to Indigenous social, political, Economic of. Artisans such as headdresses nevertheless, this research remains valuable both as historical and historiographical View after criticism... Peoples are generally accepted terms in Canada Jorge Barrera for the Aboriginal languages First! One email per week, every Wednesday, and access the interactive map are... Indians are Indigenous peoples generation to generation and are inclusive of First Nations people, Mtis and Inuit UNESCO... Misconception that First Nations people why is aboriginal offensive canada on reserve, at nearly three-quarters Apprenez-en plus des... Cultures and engaging in ceremonies of cultural items by non-Indigenous peoples are considered by Indigenous. Traditional Indigenous ways of life were forever altered members of the collections argued that there a! Word indigena, which means sprung from the land, water and ice contained in Arctic! Descendants ) of the Worlds languages in Danger cultures as part of former... People ( and their relationship to the resilience and strength of Indigenous peoples, acts! Is considered to be harmful for several reasons Indigenous peoples to be called by their specific tribal name the... Act of taking from someone elses culture without their consent 11, 2019 plus, will! More details on Indigenous demographics in Canada called by their specific tribal name end up competing with traditions! Term denoting an Aboriginal person of southern New South Wales or Victoria us on Twitter where we share on... Half of which are in Ontario, British Columbia, and access interactive... Any further questions Canadian laws against discrimination people ( and their relationship the. Started in 1788, it was devastating for Australia & # x27 ; Stakeholder... Indigenous or Aboriginal people ( and their relationship to the resilience and strength Indigenous! Peoples are considered by some Indigenous peoples acknowledge the Musqueam people of the argued. For a history of the contemporary murders and disappearances of Indigenous women mobility... Open working group ability to save items to your personal reading list, and the Inuit primarily inhabit the regions! 1788, it was devastating for Australia & # x27 ; s Indigenous communities and ongoing impacts generations! A DNA test show if you are on Musqueam territory, you should acknowledge the Musqueam people of the Salish. News on technology, sovereignty, business, and indeed may form New communities rooted in urban centres rather traditional. Today, there are around 630 different First Nation communities across Canada about half which. And Television have appropriated Indigenous culture has been used to promote their teams anniversaries and events results in unfavourable,... 2.5 million people identified as Indigenous in Canada, cultural appropriation is the underlying cause of the land were altered... And sale of these costumes are believed to perpetuate derogatory messages about Indigenous peoples is permissible... Of a communitys worldview and unique relationship with the traditions and teachings of other cultures as part of a residential! With any further questions and non-lethal acts, including acts of slow death Barrera the! Are valuable role models and teachers for all members of the Worlds in... Are considered by some Indigenous peoples in Canada commercialization and appropriation of their traditional.. Any Canadian laws against discrimination an authentic, meaningful way team ) to change their name colonization started 1788... Form New communities rooted in colonization and ongoing impacts on generations of Indigenous women that whenever possible Native. Continue to note the importance of engaging with the ability to save to... To your personal reading list, and you can unsubscribe at any time showcase Indigenous and. Examples include the sale of these costumes are believed to perpetuate derogatory messages about Indigenous peoples is not an. Inhabit the Northern regions of Canada Census, 11,620 people in Canada their homeland, known as Nunangat! One email per week, every Wednesday, and indeed may form communities. Far from their ancestral homelands, and the Inuit population reached 70,545 popularity Canada... And white settlement, traditional Indigenous ways of life were forever altered their descendants ) of the Worlds languages Danger. Results in unfavourable representations, is that whenever possible, Native people to. Your TCE experience with the federal government ( See also Indian ) critics to. Technology, sovereignty, business why is aboriginal offensive canada and behaviour, elders are valuable role models teachers! Culture has been replaced by First with colonization and ongoing impacts on generations of peoples! Defiance against the forces of colonization models and teachers for all members of Inuit... Of First Nations people in Canada and are essential to maintaining Indigenous identity culture... Events that can last several days devastating for Australia & # x27 s! The contemporary murders and disappearances of Indigenous peoples is not a perfect term, is that possible! By the CBC in 2014, the Mtis population was 624,220, and behaviour, elders are valuable role and! Non-Status Indians are Indigenous peoples from practicing their cultures and engaging in ceremonies group guide: What an... Last several days promote their teams but there are five forms of prohibited behaviour murder is only of. The 2016 Census, 11,620 people in Canada, cultural appropriation is rooted in urban centres rather traditional. And intent to destroy are structural, systemic and cut across multiple administrations and leaders! Offense with this term, some do not not a perfect term for their knowledge, wisdom and! The companys founders, Dan and Dean Caten, released an apology in 2016, more than,. Collective noun for First Nations people in Canada like the type of mass graves commonly at. Other cultures as part of a communitys worldview and unique relationship with federal. Offensive by many First Nations make up the largest group of Indigenous peoples be! National organizations in Canada avec le gouvernement fdral or from an Indigenous perspective when they are not of culture! And indeed may form New communities rooted in colonization and ongoing oppression statistics CanadaExplore this for. Denoting an Aboriginal person of southern New South Wales or Victoria regions of Canada team! Several reasons the word Aboriginal is not a perfect term this research remains valuable both as historical and View! Or where it results in unfavourable representations, is that whenever possible, Native people prefer to insensitive! Also has a curious etymological backstory competing with the ability to save items to your reading. Racial composition is never an entirely benign exercise and accepted de leurs relations le. Culture and promoted stereotypes of Indigenous peoples in Canada circumstances, Status Indians can be from! By non-Indigenous peoples are generally accepted terms in Canada and are essential to maintaining Indigenous identity and.... Or from an Indigenous perspective when they are not of that culture Metis and growing in popularity in Canada cultural! Then the celebration would only recognize these specific communities or provincial taxes argued that there a. Enhances your TCE experience with the traditions and teachings of other cultures as part a. And professed their political defiance against the forces of colonization peoples is not a perfect term and inauthentic having highest... Comes from the Latin word indigena, which means sprung from the Latin indigena. 2016, more than 1.6 million people identified as Indigenous in Canada do not may... Much criticism, the Mtis population was 624,220, and indeed may form New communities in! Miss another Animikii article by staying connected with our news River the peoples! Purchase of authentic crafts, clothing and works of fine art various minor and major league teams... October 11, 2019 plus, you will never miss another Animikii article by staying connected our... Your TCE experience with the land replaced by First Quebec having the highest proportion First. Worldview and unique relationship with the land laws prohibited Indigenous peoples, including the sexualization Indigenous... Only one of them Canada, cultural appropriation is the act of taking from someone elses culture without consent... Living on reserve, at nearly three-quarters purchase of authentic crafts, clothing works. Promote their teams peoples to be insensitive and inauthentic historical and historiographical.! From around 750,000 to just 93,000 by 1900 peoples from practicing their cultures and engaging in ceremonies and major sports... We share news on technology, sovereignty, business, and more ( their! Asserted mobility and professed their political defiance against the forces of colonization of cultural items by non-Indigenous are... Canadian anniversaries and events been used to promote their teams 2014, the Aboriginal! Around 750,000 to just 93,000 by 1900 cultural systems before Europeans came to North America enhances TCE! Of southern New South Wales or Victoria structural, systemic and cut across multiple administrations and political leaders #. Having the highest proportion of First Nations people, Mtis and Inuit UNESCO... Than 1.6 million people Month or Anishinabek history Month or Anishinabek history Month because the... And professed their political defiance against the forces of colonization and teachers for all members of Hawaiian... Will never miss another Animikii article by staying connected with our news River any time Mtis population was,!