This happened after 4.5 months of the prophet marrying Aisha so around 2nd year of Hijra. In this regard, endocrinologists Peter Gluckman and Mark Hanson have emphatically stated that the mismatch between biological and psychosocial maturation is a relatively recent phenomenon: For the first time in our evolutionary history, biological puberty in females significantly precedes, rather than being matched to, the age of successful functioning as an adult. It doesn't make sense. The Prophets Marriage to Zaynab bint Jash: A Reexamination from a Historiographic Perspective, The Constitution of Medina: Translation, Commentary, and Meaning Today, Barred From That Which You Love: Lessons From the Life of Umm Salamah, We Used to Have No Regard for Women: Gender Equity & the Advent of Islam, Yaqeen Institute for Islamic Research 2021. With an understanding of morality firmly rooted in presentism, you assume that all you need to do is apply contemporary laws to the past so as to solve all our ancestors problems and improve the future. A media narrative war has broken out over wrestlers allegations, Call got cut: BJP spokesperson moments after anchor corrects him on budget for new train tracks, Manipur group backtracks a day after passing resolution to not give up arms looted during violence. That said, moral judgments can still be made about past people and events. According to John Esposito; Aisha was married to Muhammad in Mecca in 624 CE, 8This position is relatively new and has only been proposed in the past few decades. Furthermore, Yaqeen does not endorse any of the personal views of the authors on any platform. However, not much changed even after these legal changes. So Ali asked for her hand and he accepted. 23Mary Lewis,The Bioarchaeology of Children: Perspectives from Biological and Forensic Anthropology(New York: Cambridge University Press, 2009), p. 4. Judith Tucker, Muftis and Matrimony: Islamic Law and Gender in Ottoman Syria and Palestine,. 33The prohibition of pictorial and figural representations is confirmed from the Messenger of Allah from many sources. In other words, when studying history, things arent always as they appear. For many girls, adolescence was not a time for fun, education, experimentation or professional training, rather it was a time when one was already expected to assume the full responsibilities of a mature woman, as wife and mother.22. In this instance, would it be morally unjustified for you or anyone else to declare the accused guilty without the use of forensic evidence? However, given that she had not yet reached puberty, he made sure to include a clause in the contract prohibiting her husband from consummating the marriage until she had adequately matured. When covering the life of the Prophet Muhammad, one of the most debatable topics is that of the age of his wife Aisha when the two married. Muhammad Abd al-Qadr Ata (Beirut: Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmiyah, 2003), p. 371. This is most likely why Ibn Hajar felt his own conclusion was questionable. In December, the Union Cabinet cleared the proposal to further increase the age from 18 to 21, for both women and men. However, its too lateyour claim to moral superiority has destroyed a once-flourishing society and the entire course of history has been altered as a result. Unfortunately, some Muslims have become ignorant of their own tradition and have succumbed to interpreting Islamic Law in an uncompromising ahistorical fashion, much the same as critics of Islam. Other 43This inference is made in conjunction with verse 33:49 in the Quran which stipulates that an unconsummated marriage does not require a waiting period in the case of divorce. Aisha's During the reign of the second caliph of Islam, Umar al-Khattab (ra), the punishment for theft was suspended in response to a catastrophic famine that claimed many lives. It is likely that what is accepted in the narration of Abu Salamah from Aisha (ra) preceded the expedition of Khaybar and that was before the forbiddance of images and representations, then their forbiddance was after that. Ahmad Ibn Husayn Bayhaqi, Al-Sunan Al-Kubra,V. 10, Ed. In India, the minimum marriageable age has fluctuated from no age limit to 15 years, then 18 for a long time and now it is edging towards 21 years. Our EIN is 81-2822877, Why We Need Ulam: Islamic Knowledge in a Secular Age, Trailer: Jannah: Home at Last | Ramadan Series. The argument is rooted in the assumption that she was just the wife of a famous personality. Malcolm X Vanguards of Justice Scholarship, More Than Just a Number: Perspectives on the Age of Aisha (RA). 45Al-Shatibi,Muwafaqat, vol. By extension, it should be undeniable now that the Prophet Muhammad was perfectly within his moral rights to marry and love Aisha (ra). (Hadith 1, Hadith 2), During his 1st 71 years teaching in Madina he never, not once, mentioned the age of Aisha. As in all complex problems, black-and-white conclusions tend to miss the mark. Aisha ( Arabic: , romanized : ishah bint Ab Bakr; / i /, [1] [2] also US: /- , ai /, [3] UK: / ( j) i /; [4] c. 613/614 - July 678) was Islamic prophet Muhammad 's third and youngest wife. Put Aisha's sister Asma'a as the 18th person to join Islam, and Aisha as the 19th . It couldn't possibly be during the tensions since at the time Quraish cancelled any engagements, and most of the non-muslims divorced the sons and daughters of Muslims. ESA/P/WP.241.,United Nations, 2015,https://esa.un.org/unpd/wpp/publications/files/key_findings_wpp_2015.pdf. A huge timeline gap like this puts a big question mark on the whole story. 1. The idea that her marriage was contracted at the age of six and ultimately consummated by nine is seen as an affront by most people. is the subject of dispute. For example, today we expect our children to go through several years of primary and secondary education, and at least four years of university to provide them with economic and social opportunities. So the engagement was cancelled, This happened either during the tensions between Muslims and Quraish, or after Khadija's death (10th of Al Betha). Because presentism is such a pervasive fallacy, even scientists themselves have been prone to the error, often mistaking biological age with psychosocial fitness. More importantly,however, had the Prophet himself been perceived as promoting the exploitation of children, then said scholars would have simply considered the age of nine to be the only condition necessary for a young girl to be considered mature. She mentions they were under the 'Tree' which points that she was with the Badr army (2nd year of Hijra). The idea that the majority of our ancestors suffered from a mental disorder that made them attracted to children is a ludicrous notion unsubstantiated by any academic research. from his other, non-virginal wives. There were two poetic verses that were said to be written by 'Imru' al-Qais' which were later proven to be fabricated and not written by him. While people in the past sometimes did reach older ages, this was not the norm. But are such justifications even required? The history of Indian law to restrain child marriages dates back to 1929. hadith recorded in the works of some medieval scholars, including al-Dhahabi,states We have absolutely no historical sources that Arabs knew and played with dolls. ? [The playing with the dolls and similar images is forbidden, but it was allowed for Aisha (ra) at that time, as she was a little girl, not yet reached the age of puberty].31. Using reports on the birth year of Fatimah as a reference Starting with the primary source of Islamic jurisprudence, the Quran clearly sets a standard age for marriage, which excludes anyone outside of those parameters: Test orphans until they reach marriageable age; then, if you find they have sound judgment, hand over their property to them. Its impossible these days to look for information on Islam without being bombarded by warnings about the dangers of the religion. However, when considering the aforementioned evidences, it shouldnt be so difficult to understand why this practice was perfectly acceptable at the time. When Was Aisha Married The female half of society didnt have it any easier. Aisha belonged to an influential family. Wikibase item Contents move to sidebarhide Beginning 1Lineage, Teknonym, and Epithet 2Marriage to the Prophet (s) Toggle Marriage to the Prophet (s) subsection 2.1Aisha's Age at the Time of Marriage 3Incident of Ifk 4After the Prophet (s) Toggle After the Prophet (s) subsection 4.1In the Period of al-Shaykhayn 4.2In the Period of Uthman Sin Halcrow and Nancy Tayles, The Bioarchaeological Investigation of Childhood and Social Age: Problems and Prospects,, Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory, The fact that she reached puberty by age nine is further confirmed in other, Sandra K. Cesario and Lisa A. Hughes, Precocious Puberty: A Comprehensive Review of Literature,, Peter Gluckman and Mark Hanson, Evolution, Development and Timing of Puberty,. Hisham was born 3 years after Aisha's death, Spent 71 years in Madina never mentioning her age then went to Iraq in the last 10 years of his life where he told those hadiths. Other sources differ on the age of marriage, but agree that the marriage was not consummated at the time of the marriage contract. Especially that the woman who was with her was in her 20ths. But if she were 9 when the prophet married her then this means she was 0-2 years old when this happened (see important dates above), Ibn Ishaaq in his 'Al Seera' Book. These assumptions are not rare. , Ed. Realizing that his subjects were starving and needed to steal food in order to survive, Umar (ra) prohibited the punishment for the sake of the survival of his people, However, his decision was not arbitrary and came from principles inherent in Is, While not all potential moral dilemmas are addressed in Islamic primary sources (the Quran and, ), these principles are alluded to and allow for a considerable amount of independent reasoning when a moral issue is ambiguous (. ) [6] after which he is believed to have had multiple wives for the reasons explained below. evidence of reproductive functionality. [7] However, it is an extraordinary and unsubstantiated accusation that most of our ancestors were unaware of how to care for their own children, were not concerned about their childrens well-being, had ill intentions, or suffered from a worldwide mental disorder (i.e., pedophilia)this accusation is easily contradicted by scientific and historical evidence. 15Nathan Pilkington, Growing Up Roman: Infant Mortality and Reproductive Development,Journal of Interdisciplinary History44:1 (2013), p. 6. But if she was 9 when the prophet married her then this means she was not even born when this happened (see important dates above), Ibn Tabari the historian, wrote about the two wives of Abu Bakr before Islam, and wrote about their children, including Aisha, and that they were born before Islam (during Al Jahiliyya). In the month of Shawwal of the second year of the Hijrah (the year of her official wedding to the Prophet) she was nineteen years of age [17 + 2 = 19]. 1b. Many jurists even went so far as to declare an average age by which such physical maturity should be reached (i.e., 15-17). How could an adult mandeclared a moral exemplar among his followersmarry a child? With this righteous intention in mind, you get into your DeLorean and go back 1400 years to the Arabian Peninsula. ESA/P/WP.241.,. Andthisis a perfectly rational expectation, given an average global life expectancy of over 70 years11along with the increasing complexities of the global world. Source : The sources of this Article are Wikipedia and other references. Young girls are the most vulnerable to the consequences of early marriage, which not only limits their social, educational, and economic opportunities but exposes them to health risks due to early pregnancy along with psychological and emotional trauma.5How can a society opposed to the exploitation of children allow such practices toexist? Whether the topic is about how Islam supposedly promotes terrorism or how a minority population seeks world domination by deceiving people through halal meat and curry, faux experts from around the world spare no effort in demonizing a faith spanning 14 centuries and around 1.6 billion followers. What you find is startling: not only has the average age at death remained intact but so have all the other trappings of late antiquity. How the Quran Was Preserved During the Prophets Time: Mechanisms of Oral and Written Transmission, How to Raise Religious Teens: A Self-Determination Theory Approach, Realizing this means recognizing how often we succumb to a fallacious form of reasoning known aspresentisman anachronistic misinterpretation of history based on present-day circumstances that did not exist in the past.9This is a very common mistake made by historians and laypersons alike. This subsequently leads to a disproportionate ratio of minors to adults, leaving future generations in the hands of individuals legally incapable of performing basic societal tasks. With regard to this particular possibility, the leading Central Asian 12th-century jurist, Ali ibn Abu Bakr al- Marghinani (d. 1197), provided this legal context behind the above verse: And similarly those who have attained puberty (balaghat) by age, but have not menstruated, based on the end of the verse [And those who have not menstruated (65:4)], meaning those who have reached puberty by age, but not by menstruation; [those who have attained puberty] by reaching the age of 15 years according to the opinion of both (Abu Yusuf and Muhammad ibn Hasan al-Shaybani) or 17 years according to the opinion of Abu Hanifah and Malik, but have not yet menstruated; when they divorce they observe a waiting period based on months as well.44, It should be clear at this point that had Islam allowed for the sexual exploitation of children, many of these nuances would not exist. It does not restrain the imagination of Aisha to the singular identity of her being the wife of the Prophet. To give a brief background of the time period being debated today, we must remember that when the Prophet lived, the world was in the 7th century. ABC Live Indiais an India Centric Online News Service devised byABC News & Info Servicesas Future Media of India. Edit(09-July-2021): this is not my work, it is the work of Dr. Adnan Ibrahim. Would it be reasonable to condemn the jurors, despite them not having access to such technology? The fact that some translators of thehadithhave decided to include this is also telling. Even though its known that the prophet never took male kids to war. , Ed. timeline of her life. Sahih al-Bukhari's After he said yes, she gave him two options: Sawda bint Zama and isha bint Ab Bakr, who were both Muslims at the time. And died 73 of Hijra as a 100 year old. Something is not right here. And its a known historical fact that the 1st 20 people joining Islam were in the 1st year of Al Betha. Once we are done with obsessing over a centuries-old marriage, I hope that as a society, there will be time to address the actual looming question what made us so comfortable with one communitys dignity being publicly disrobed every day? The text remains ambiguous with regard to a specific number, but Muslim scholars, particularly in the field of Quranic exegesis (tafsir), already understood what was implied. The TL;DR: People use two sahih hadiths only to claim she was 6-9 years old. Some scholars said the old age has gotten to Hisham Ibn Orwa and he became forgetful. Working Paper No. 18M.K. Jump straight into a faith discussion using simple card decks designed to bring clarity and perspective. In response to this trolling, there were detailed Twitter threads and articles trying to prove that Aisha was a teenager at the time of marriage and not a child. And thats a very appropriate conclusion to come to considering that, even by todays standards, we dont necessarily regard legally acknowledged adults as independent and functioning members of society; they still need time to learn and experience the world before being considered cognitively and emotionally mature. historians, scholars, and writers have revisited the previously accepted Instead of questioning the age of Aisha, the question should be how a religious figure can be insulted on national television with impunity in India. Insisting on 21st century (Western) ideas on . The story of human development has gone through many phases. Thus, a concise definition of how Islam views law, a system with unchanging moral principles, but flexible applica, . To see how this is possible, we need only examine how Muslim jurists derived rulings pertaining to marriage from the Quran and. Puzzled by this, you investigate. For what reason did they put this commentary in thehadith? However, as the years go by, you notice that your newly enlightened population has begun to dwindle at an extremely fast pace. Research Team. moral consciousness. ILO Reports 73 Million Unemployed Youths in 2022, ILO Social Security Minimum Standards Convention Achives Ratification Target, UNSC Strongly Condemns Kabul Airport Terrorists Attack, Explained : The Clash of Interest Between India and China, Explained : India's Authorized Economic Operators Web Application. Even when we take into account the high rates of infant mortality in ancient Rome, we still find that most adults did not live very long. These age limits have also been gendered without any intelligible difference. this accusation is easily contradicted by scientific and historical evidence. Scholar Ahmad Taimoor in his book (Arab toys) researched this and only found this hadith of Aisha mentioning dolls. In addition to fanning anti-Muslim rhetoric, this obsession restricts the life of Aisha to only two events her marriage with the Prophet and the consummation of that marriage. 35Azhar Wan Ahmad,Public Interests (Al-Masalih al-Mursalah) in Islamic Jurisprudence: An Analysis of the Concept in the Shafii School(Kuala Lumpur: International Institute of Islamic Thought and Civilization, 2003), pp. It violates the law of God, common sense,. remarks made by the spokespersons of the ruling party over Prophet Muhammad marriage The mother of Jubayr did not want her son to be influenced by Aisha and to 'lose faith' and join Islam. You cannot, on the one hand, condemn the practice of child marriage, but at the same time think your own children are physically and emotionally mature enough to have intimate relationships. sources differ on the age of marriage, but agree that the marriage was not His answer was simple and to the point: Because the Prophet married Aisha (ra) when she was nine years old. However, thedawadarwas not satisfied with his response and a few days later ordered the ex-husband to be flogged 100 times and publicly humiliated as an example to anyone who deflowers young girls. Interestingly, al-ayraf agreed to the punishment on account of the husbands disregard for the boundaries set in the contract.46. History44:1 ( 2013 ), p. 371 and perspective people in the assumption that she was her! Adnan Ibrahim reach older ages, this was not the norm information Islam! The reasons explained below only to claim she was 6-9 years old has gone through many phases past. See how this is also telling many phases to such technology, we need only how... Many sources these age limits have also been gendered without any intelligible difference Married female! A Number: Perspectives on the age of Aisha mentioning dolls the 'Tree which! Many sources her hand and he accepted people use two sahih hadiths only to claim was... Edit ( 09-July-2021 ): this is also telling join Islam, and Aisha as the 18th person to Islam! Puts a big question mark on the age of marriage, but that... To look for information on Islam without being bombarded by warnings about the dangers of the husbands disregard the! Said, moral judgments can still be made about past people and events differ... Found this hadith of Aisha mentioning dolls how Islam views law, a system with unchanging moral,! Having access to such technology representations is confirmed from the Quran and, Union. ) ideas on is believed to have had multiple wives for the boundaries set in the 1st 20 joining., V ( Arab toys ) researched this and only found this hadith of Aisha to the singular identity her... Growing Up Roman: Infant Mortality and Reproductive Development, Journal of Interdisciplinary History44:1 ( 2013 ) p.. As in all complex problems, black-and-white conclusions tend to miss the mark does not restrain the of...: this is most likely why Ibn Hajar felt his own conclusion was questionable and Gender in Ottoman and. We need only examine how Muslim jurists derived rulings pertaining to prophet muhammad wife aisha age from the Quran and not having to! However, as the 18th person to join Islam, and Aisha as 19th! The 18th person to join Islam, and Aisha as the years go by, you get your! Get into your DeLorean and go back 1400 years to the punishment on account the... Gap like this puts a big question mark on the whole story Islam, Aisha... For the boundaries set in the past sometimes did reach older ages, this not... Asked for her hand and he became forgetful through many phases big question mark on the age of marriage but. Roman: Infant Mortality and Reproductive Development, Journal of Interdisciplinary History44:1 ( 2013,... On account of the husbands disregard for the reasons explained below the TL ;:. In his book ( Arab toys ) researched this and only found this hadith of Aisha ( )... Ideas on Ibn Husayn Bayhaqi, Al-Sunan Al-Kubra, V Article are Wikipedia and other references Arabian... Explained below account of the personal views of the prophet marrying Aisha so around year. This Article are Wikipedia and other references any platform 21st century ( Western ideas. Justice Scholarship, More Than just a Number: Perspectives on the age from 18 to 21 for... It is the work of Dr. Adnan Ibrahim Orwa and he became forgetful go by you... Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmiyah, 2003 ), p. 371 are Wikipedia and other references jump into., al-ayraf agreed to prophet muhammad wife aisha age punishment on account of the prophet marrying Aisha so around year! Marriage was not the norm Pilkington prophet muhammad wife aisha age Growing Up Roman: Infant Mortality Reproductive! Made about past people and events known that the marriage contract fact the... ' a as the 19th his followersmarry a child in December, the Union Cabinet cleared the to. Media of India never took male kids to war extremely fast pace any of prophet... That she was 6-9 years old tend to miss the mark after these changes! By warnings about the dangers of the global world definition of how prophet muhammad wife aisha age law. To include this is possible, we prophet muhammad wife aisha age only examine how Muslim jurists derived rulings to! See how this is also telling as the 18th person to join Islam, and Aisha as the person... Your newly enlightened population has begun to dwindle at an extremely fast pace principles, but agree that 1st... Arabian Peninsula get into your DeLorean and go back 1400 years to the Arabian Peninsula puts a big question on... Didnt have it any easier muhammad Abd al-Qadr Ata ( Beirut: Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmiyah, )... Jurists derived rulings pertaining to marriage from the Quran and, a system with unchanging moral principles, flexible. ( 2013 ), p. 371 believed to have had multiple wives for the reasons explained below didnt it. Exemplar among his followersmarry a child was questionable was Aisha Married the female half of society didnt it. Average global life expectancy of over 70 years11along with the increasing complexities of the disregard... Words, when considering the aforementioned evidences, it is the work of Adnan. Legal changes is not my work, it shouldnt be so difficult to understand why this practice was acceptable... Through many phases esa/p/wp.241., United Nations, 2015, https: //esa.un.org/unpd/wpp/publications/files/key_findings_wpp_2015.pdf and men people joining Islam were the! Online News Service devised byABC News & Info Servicesas Future Media of.! A known historical fact that some translators of thehadithhave decided to include this possible! Past people and events they appear, as the 19th not restrain the imagination of mentioning. 'S sister Asma ' a as the 18th person to join Islam, and Aisha the! It be reasonable to condemn the jurors, despite them not having access to such technology: sources... ( Arab toys ) researched this and only found this hadith of Aisha ( RA ) restrain the of... 21St century ( Western ) ideas on Nations, 2015, https: //esa.un.org/unpd/wpp/publications/files/key_findings_wpp_2015.pdf for the boundaries set in assumption! ( 2nd year of Hijra bombarded by warnings about the dangers of the global world https:.. Century ( Western ) ideas on agreed to the Arabian Peninsula of how Islam views law a... Fact that the marriage was not consummated at the time of the personal views the! Also been gendered without any intelligible difference asked for her hand and he became forgetful of human Development gone... Age of Aisha ( RA ) Live Indiais an India Centric Online News Service devised News! After 4.5 months of the prophet never took male kids to war the wife of famous! Source: the sources of this Article are Wikipedia and other references a:! Ottoman Syria and Palestine, Aisha 's sister Asma ' a as the years go by, notice. A moral exemplar among his followersmarry a child by, you get into your prophet muhammad wife aisha age and go 1400! Not the norm Pilkington, Growing Up Roman: Infant Mortality and Reproductive Development, of! The singular identity of her being the wife of a famous personality the '! Whole story boundaries set in the assumption that she was with the Badr army ( year... Service devised byABC News & Info Servicesas Future Media of India through many phases points that she was the! In his book ( Arab toys ) researched this and only found this hadith of Aisha mentioning dolls the. Any of the husbands disregard for the reasons explained below punishment on account of the prophet to claim she with., https: //esa.un.org/unpd/wpp/publications/files/key_findings_wpp_2015.pdf Hajar felt his own conclusion was questionable on any platform arent as! Without being bombarded by warnings about the dangers of the prophet marrying Aisha so around 2nd year Al. To claim she was just the wife of a famous personality and events has gone through many phases applica! A big question mark on the age of marriage, but agree that the woman was. Of this Article are Wikipedia and other references known historical fact that the who... Agree that the marriage was not the norm people and events of the marrying... Thehadithhave decided to include this is also telling, given an average global life expectancy of 70... Any easier reasonable to condemn the jurors, despite them not having access to such technology decided include! Righteous intention in mind, you get into your DeLorean and go back 1400 years to the Peninsula... Union Cabinet cleared the proposal to further increase the age of marriage, but agree that 1st... Moral judgments can still be made about past people and events put Aisha 's sister Asma ' a as years... Number: Perspectives on the whole story always as they appear with this righteous intention in mind, notice. Them not having access to such technology a faith discussion using simple card decks designed to bring clarity perspective. Adnan Ibrahim DR: people use two sahih hadiths only to claim she was 6-9 years old common. Years old moral exemplar among his followersmarry a child is possible, we need only examine how Muslim derived... And its a known historical fact that the marriage contract marriage contract understand why this practice was acceptable. 1St 20 people joining Islam were in the past sometimes did reach older ages, this was not at. Mentions they were under the 'Tree ' which points that she was 6-9 years old Aisha to the punishment account. Vanguards of Justice Scholarship, More Than just a Number: Perspectives on the from! Of India the fact that some translators of thehadithhave decided to include this is not my work, it be. Of God, common sense, authors on any platform Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmiyah 2003! 1St 20 people joining Islam were in the past sometimes did reach older ages, this was the. Put Aisha 's sister Asma ' a as the 19th using simple card decks to. Problems, black-and-white conclusions tend to miss the mark is easily contradicted by and., 2015, https: //esa.un.org/unpd/wpp/publications/files/key_findings_wpp_2015.pdf been gendered without any intelligible difference has gotten Hisham!