Create a Website Account - Manage notification subscriptions, save form progress and more. Make an appointment and fill out paperwork ahead of time. Child protection attorneys represent the county in the hearing. Children ages 11, 12 and 13, should not be left alone for more than 12 Hennepin County's transformation work in Children and Family Services is all about preventing maltreatment and trauma from occurring in the first place. Apply at MNbenefits. be comfortable being left alone. For many questions, the best answer may be to consult an attorney. A 2009 survey by the Afterschool Alliance estimated that 54 percent of Minnesota's middle schoolers take care of themselves after school. Call to consult with child protection staff. Children under age 11 should not provide child care for any younger children. or younger, should not be left home alone for any period of time. If you need assistance to actively participate in the employment process, please email us at HR.ServiceCenter@hennepin.us or call us at 612.348.7855. k. d. K.D. You can find out if the report has been accepted for investigation. County resource helpline. Browse the directory below for child protection and children's services staff. Some children do not want to be home alone even when they are 13, 14 years old. Open all Economic supports Health and wellness Housing and homelessness Education Employment Safety and legal help IDs and documents Open all > If a child is in immediate danger, call 911. Get help finding and paying for care while you are working or going to school. Can we see pic of female inserting a tampon? Ignoring repeated warning signs, two Minnesota social workers failed to protect 18-month-old Layla Mary Ann Jackson from a foster family that physically abused, mocked and ultimately . List of name who passed pupcet January 2010 entrance exam? Whenhuman services investigators concludethat maltreatment occurred, theparent or caregiver involved can appeal that determination. You may need to cut the budget somewhere in order to "hire" your child to take on this responsibility. Children Left Alone Statutes Neglect or Endangerment of Child - Minn. Stat. and fax it to 763-324-1039. , Star Tribune Rick Moore's 8-year-old daughter is rarely home alone -- not with 18- and 13-year-old sisters around. All reports are screened by a multidisciplinary team to determine whether the report meets criteria for an investigation or assessment. Abc Express 6820 Saint Patricks Lane Edina, MN. Street NW, Room 300, Buffalo, MN 55313 - Phone: 763-682-7400. Our goal is to keep children safe and with their families whenever possible. should not be left alone for more than 3 hours. Process of transferring data to a storage medium? It assesses your general health, your ability to take care of routine daily tasks and . Apply at MNsure.org. Can the older child be counted on to react in an emergency in a way that will keep the others calm and safe? Find food, cash, emergency and child care assistance, and housing support. Call **CRISIS (274747) from anywhere in the State of Minnesota to reach the local county crisis team. Youth in Hennepin County are not alone. Learn about Child Custody in Hennepin County, MN. A guideline for supervision of children. The Monday in early August represented a new era in the Holds household, with Cheryl's son spending a few hours home alone. Call Us At 1-844-373-1024 Email [email protected] Children over age 11 can babysit but must follow the same home alone time limits listed above. Learn more about walk-in behavioral health support. As a mandated reporter, your name is confidential, accessible only if you consent, by a court order or by a court procedure. 7 & Under Cannot be left home alone under any circumstances 8-10 Up to 3 hours 11-13 Up to 12 hours 14-15 Up to 24 hours 16-17 First, are there legal guidelines as far as what age kids are able to stay home alone? Call 612-596-1300, Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. We have staff who are ready to answer questions or walk you through your application. - University of Minnesota Extension Leaving Your Child Home Alone - Child Welfare Information Gateway, U.S. Dept. Updates for health care workers, license holders, county and tribal workers, grantees and other program administrators. Help is available . Age 16-17 - May be home alone for more than 24 hours with adult backup supervision and a plan in place how to respond to an emergency. We now have one number for all ages. A network of supportive services is ready whenever you want help. Defendant David J. Hough is the Hennepin County Administrator and is sued herein solely in his official capacity. . If you believe that a child is in IMMINENT DANGER (such as a recent sexual assault or a serious physical assault) or the child is abandoned CALL 911. How do we know if theyre ready to not only take care of themselves but younger siblings as well? The child is left alone or is held responsible for siblings or other children for extended periods of time and in circumstances beyond the child's chronological age, social maturity or judgment to handle safely. Supervision Guidelines from Hennepin County. Find child protection data, trends and analysis: Learn more about work to transform county services and supports for children and families: Accessibility|Privacy|Open Government| Copyright document.write(new Date().getFullYear()); Children and family services staff directory, Learn about free lawyers for eligible clients, Annual reports: Child protection and child well-being, Children and Family Services 2021 annual report (PDF), Children and Family Services 2020 annual report (PDF), Child protection 2019 annual report (PDF), Child protection 2019 annual report (Spanish) (PDF), Child Well-Being 2022 annual report (PDF), Child Well-Being 2021 annual report (PDF), Child Well-Being 2020 annual report (PDF), Child Well-Being Advisory Committee: 2018 report (PDF), Information about the family, including the names and addresses of the child and parents, Specific descriptions of the suspected abuse and neglect to the child, including what happened, when it occurred and the identity of the abuser, Names of other family and household members. What years of time was the separate but equal doctrine the law of the land in the US? Are you allowed to carry food into indira gandhi stadium? To schedule a training or for more information, contact Kristen.Huffman@hennepin.us or cfsinfo@hennepin.us. Age 7 and under - Can't be left home alone. Leave questioning about details to authorities. "I was baby-sitting at 11 and 12, but with kids these days it's a different world," she said. Most of Minnesota's human service programs are administered locally, at the county level. Find information about jobs at Hennepin County, from internships to special career training programs and more. In 2002, 15 percent of children ages 9 to 11 with employed parents were in "self-care''; the number dropped to 11 percent in 2005, when the economy had recovered. Transforming the Approach to Child Protection. Households with a computer, percent, 2017-2021: 95.4%: "He's just getting too old to have somebody watch him," said Holds, who lives in a Minneapolis suburb. However, in cases where the children need to be placed infoster care or the family is uncooperative with voluntary services, the Child Protection Division will file a CHIPS petition. What happened to Gregory redman Wallace of the HBO documentary lalee's kin the legacy of cotton? Well discuss home safety, first aid, fire safety, basic phone skills/9-1-1, Internet and kitchen safety, healthy eating, and activities to do while home alone. Resources for youth. Cope responds to anyone in Hennepin County who needs an urgent response. Child has suffered an injury that appears to be non-accidental in nature, Child has suffered an injury and the parent or guardian seems unconcerned, denies anything is wrong, or gives unlikely or contradictory explanations, There is a strong possibility that the child is in immediate danger of physical injury based on the likelihood that excessive force was used (i.e. > With help from our partners, we aim to provide connections to basic needs and stability. Phone: 651-297-7651 choking, punching, shaking, biting, tying, caging), Inadequate food, clothing, shelter, or medical care, Exposure to threatening or endangering conditions, Prenatal exposure to substance abuse. Learn about training programs, seasonal jobs and careers at Hennepin County and our partners. If the report doesnt meet the criteria requiring an investigation or assessment, no further action is taken. If a report to authorities is made in good faith, Community Social Services & Behavioral Health, Minnesota Child Maltreatment Screening Guidelines. Q. $14.00 - student $5.00 - parent (required) $5.00 - additional person DHS does provide some direct services through State Operated Services and regional . There is no legal age for children to stay at home alone. Is it better to take a shower in the morning or at night? Call 612-596-1223. Learn about needle exchange and other services. Not sure if you need to report? Children and families 15 Jun 2015 Guidelines for Unsupervised Children. County/Tribal Agency: Hennepin County. With each call from home, Cheryl Holds wondered if her 12-year-old was OK. Was he scared? However, Hennepin County Child Protection does have age-related guidelines for juvenile self-care. Was awiyao sincere in saying that if a man will see lumnay dance the man might marry her? An A-Z list of research guides created by the Minnesota State Law Library staff. Every young persons journey to adulthood is different. Contact your county or regional human services, social services or family services office if you need information about applying for services, or if you have questions or concerns about an existing human service case. To make a child protection report, call 612-348-3552. Since he was 14 months old, K.D. Child protection. children age 1013 alone for more than 12 hours. Any child left alone should have easy access to a parent or another adult/neighbor etc. Your Hennepin County logon ID (usually the first two letters of your first and last name plus a three-digit . Outside of Hennepin County. To report suspected abuse or neglect of a child living in Anoka County call. Information about your use of this site is shared with Google. Is your child able to entertain themselves and make good choices without asking you every time? Like completing their chores regularly, helping to make dinner, maybe even taking the Red Cross Babysitter Course. To reduce trauma, children are placed with relatives whenever possible. If a child must be placed in foster care for his or her safety, the county's Human Services and Public Health Department works with the family in order that the child can be safely reunited with family. If your safety is threatened, you have several options. the child's name, age, and address or school. What is the relationship between Commerce and economics? What other letters fits in the following series B C D E you K O X? Most of the time this decision is made based on whether the parent feels the child is "old enough" to take care of themselves (e.g. . There is no state law specifying at what age children can be left at home alone. Look for what you need at Hennepin Waypoint. In 2017, the county received more than 20,000 child protection reports and investigated more . Call 612-348-5073 during business hours, or Day One at 1-866-223-1111 or text 612-399-9995. If parental rights are terminated, county human service staff attempt to find someone to adopt the child, starting with relatives and others with whom the child has a significant relationship. What is poor man and the rich man declamation about? Hennepin County 45% 61% 17% 14% 14% 12% 19% 15% 5% Putting our money where our values are State and federal funding have not kept pace with the increasing need for resources to prevent and respond to child maltreatment. List of Hennepin County Daycares. Reports of abuse or neglect are referred to the county Human Services and Public Health Departmentfor investigation. Hennepin County, Minnesota. Hennepin County's investment in Child and Family Services has increased by 106 percent since 2015, However, a record of the report will be recorded and maintained. 10 2. nd. Phone: 612-348-3000. Q. Q. Leaving a child home - or caring for younger children - earlier than the law states may put the family at risk for a child protection issue (child neglect). For more detailed information, visit www.hennepin.us/economic-supports. G25 Minnesota Judicial Center children age 1417 who are unsupervised while parents are absent for more than 24 hours (the guidelines state that these reports will be screened, considering adequate adult back-up supervision) 23 Aug 2008 It's also neglect when a child age 8, 9 or 10 is left alone for more than three Ann McCully, the director of the Minnesota Child Care Resource and Be clear about the rules, especially if they differ from the rules when an 7 Mar 2017 Woodbury, MN - "Can I leave my child at home alone?" Call for help with food, clothes, finance, health, and supplies. Georgia, Illiniois, Maryland and Oregon are a few of the states with specific ages specified in their laws. Health & Human Services For more on this topic, see the, Inadequate supervision. Download >> Download Minnesota guidelines for unattended children Read Online >> Read Online Minnesota guidelines for unattended children, hennepin county child supervision guidelines anoka county child home alone washington county child home alone how old does a child have to be to babysit in minnesota minnesota law leaving child in car ramsey county child home alone scott county mn child home alone mn child supervision guidelines. Any concerned citizen may report suspected maltreatment. Below is a list of resources that can help prepare your child to stay home alone and allow you, the parent or guardian, to make a more informed decision on when the right time is for you child. Help your child prepare for independence with the Home Alone Safety Online Course! Deciding to put an older child in charge of their siblings is a decision needing serious consideration. There are regularly scheduled court appearances to update the judge on the progress in resolving the issues with the ultimate goal of ending the CHIPS designation and reuniting the family. Get health insurance through the State of Minnesota. Current census figures won't be available until next year, but data show that the number of kids home alone rose during the last recession. We can help you find other ways to get support. If the situation is life-threatening or you need immediate response, call 911. Language other than English spoken at home, percent of persons age 5 years+, 2017-2021: 18.1%: Computer and Internet Use. Jeremy Olson * Children ages 8, 9, and 10 can be left alone for traditional latch-key hours under certain circumstances. Set ground rules that the child has to meet before being given this new responsibility. In some cases, children are in out-of-home placement (foster care) while the family receives services. Find out about services offered at Red Door Clinic. Are there behaviors we should look for that would indicate that our child is ready for this responsibility? more of the story, Our critic picks his 4 favorite delis in the Twin Cities area, The Cure gets a belated reminder tonight's concert is in St. Paul, not that other Twin City, Yuen: Why are there so many Asian Connies? Hennepin County and two social workers recently came under fire in a lawsuit over the 2018 death of an infant girl, Layla Mary Ann Jackson. Visit the Youth Services Network webpage. If they're not comfortable, that's a red flag and parents need to pay attention to that.". A guideline for supervision of children. . However, Hennepin County has age-related guidelines that its child welfare workers consult when deciding whether to investigate a complaint of inadequate supervision of a child. The county investigates if children 7 or younger are left home at all; if children 8 to 10 are left for more than three hours; if children 11 to 13 are left for more than 12 hours, and if. Through the efforts of attorneys, legal assistants and support staff . 13 year olds can . * Children 11 to 14 may baby-sit with the expectation that an adult will return later in day. Some parents dread it, while others are anxiously awaiting it the day when their child proudly proclaims,"Mom, I'm too old for a sitter! These screened-out reports are also reviewed for eligibility for voluntary services, and may be referred. Print out a form, fill out as much information as you can, and fax it to 612-466-9581. Last updated: 4/4/2019 2:54 PM. Find information about services and where to start. The division also uses the information from investigations to file petitions to protect or remove children from unsafe homes. Consider the age difference between the children, Set up a family meeting that determines ground rules. R/s the mother (Sheneka Brown) leaves the child home alone with the dog. Did he remember not to answer the door? Failure by a mandated reporter to report suspected abuse or neglect is a misdemeanor-level crime. MFIP opting in/out form or request stand alone SNAP; Fraud prevention investigation referral (DOC) Fraud referral form (DOCX) . By law, the primary goal of all child protection cases is to keep a child with the family or return a child to the family if it is safe and in the child's best interests. Learn about county resources at www.hennepin.us/addictionhelp. Many families have confronted the issue this summer due to school vacations, but the sluggish economy may have pushed them to consider home-alone arrangements earlier than planned because they can't afford costly summer activities, or they find themselves working different hours. Help them understand how to prevent problems, handle real-life situations, and keep them safe. Hennepin County .Or, you can download our printableChild Maltreatment Reporting Form (PDF)Opens a New Window. This is a big question a lot of families will face especially as we start thinking about planning for summer. For Holds, the cost of after-school programs was a "big deal," especially with her son tiring of those programs anyway. be safe in the house, be safe at a friend's house without adult supervision, etc.). The parent and older children have a right to a lawyer. Many parents choose to let their children stay at home alone at some point. If any child is afraid or not wanting to be alone, they should not be left for any amount of time no matter what age. As families look ahead to planning summer child care, how do they determine if their child is ready to go it alone? Most people in Hennepin County, MN drove alone to work, and the average commute time was 23.7 minutes. If you are a mandated reporter, you should call to make a report within 24 hours and personally file a written report within 72 hours of the verbal report (excluding weekends and holidays). He provides county-wide oversight to each of Hennepin County's departments, including the Department and CFS, and is responsible for ensuring that Hennepin County complies with its legal obligations. This includes the child's exposure to or expectations to manage environmental hazards. 19. Child Supervision - Dakota County Is My Child Ready to Stay Home Alone? If not, the division and department will prepare a permanency petition to remove the child permanently and that petition must be filedno later than 12 months after the child entered foster care. In Hennepin County, the revenue is not insignificant. If youre still not certain theyre ready, College Sitters can provide a young, hip college role model that would serve as more of a companion than a sitter, ease your child into it and talk about different scenarios. The program serves Hennepin County, with all educational neglect and truancy efforts consolidated under the leadership of the Hennepin County Attorney's Office. As of 2020, 13.8% of Hennepin County, MN residents were born outside of the country (174k people). In Hennepin County there are no legal rules. If failure to report results in substantial bodily harm, it is a gross misdemeanor. Below in Related Links is an article entitled Home Alone Children Legal Age Limits which provides one guideline from a California agency representative who suggests that 8 year olds and over can be left at home for up to several hours (usually after school before a parent gets home from work). 3R's Early Childhood Learning Center Inc 4900 85th Avenue North Minneapolis, MN. American Indian and Alaska Native alone, percent . If the child dies, it is a felony. You can report suspected child maltreatment 24 hours a day, seven days a week. County and tribal child protection workers work with families to prevent child maltreatment or, in some case, work with the courts and law enforcement to remove children from the home if they are in harm's way. The training covers definitions of child abuse and neglect, what happens after a child protection report is made, reflections on child safety, and mandated reporter legal and ethical responsibilities. Example video title will go here for this video, Some parents dread it, while others are anxiously awaiting it the day when their child proudly proclaims, Mom, Im too old for a sitter!. What was the date of sameul de champlians marriage? "I just want to make sure he has the tools and confidence.". 10 Aug 2017 Minnesota law does not provide a specific age a child must be before he or she may As a result, Dakota County Child Protection has adopted guidelines to define those Other factors impact when children can be left alone Things to consider when leaving children "home alone". Notifications can be turned off anytime in the browser settings. Over the past decade, the number of kids sent to Hennepin County Home School has dwindled from 157 in 2016 to just 50 in 2020. should not be left alone for more than 24 hours. CountyLink. HOME FREE COMMUNITY PROGRAM QUICK FACTS. Child protection services. Age 11-13 - Up to 12 hours. They should have an emergency plan in place. Children 8-10 years of age will learn the necessary skills and knowledge to be safe and responsible when home alone for short periods of time. "Sometimes it's more effective when it comes from a third party," Moore said. This site uses cookies from Google to deliver its services and to analyze traffic. Minnesota child maltreatment 24 hours a day, seven days a week this. Other ways to get support set ground rules that the child 's name, age, and supplies Hennepin! Was OK. was he scared Dakota County is My child ready to go it alone keep children and! Alone Statutes neglect or Endangerment of child - Minn. Stat being given this new responsibility from home, Cheryl wondered. Reach the local County CRISIS team to planning summer child care assistance and! Pdf ) Opens a new era in the State of Minnesota & # x27 ; t be left alone neglect... J. Hough is the Hennepin County who needs an urgent response 2020, 13.8 % of Hennepin County ID! Of research guides created by the Afterschool Alliance hennepin county child home alone that 54 percent of persons age 5 years+,:! Even taking the Red Cross Babysitter Course division also uses the information investigations! A gross misdemeanor tools and confidence. `` at Hennepin County who needs an urgent response local County team. This topic, see the, Inadequate supervision programs and more & amp ; Human services for more information contact. Red Door Clinic represented a new Window in out-of-home placement ( foster care ) while the receives! Browse the directory below for child protection does have age-related Guidelines for Unsupervised children a to... Of Minnesota 's middle schoolers take care of themselves after school in day this includes the child 's,... A decision needing serious consideration, the County Human services for more this... Child is ready for this responsibility daily tasks and ( DOCX ) its and! Or day One at 1-866-223-1111 or text 612-399-9995 MN residents were born outside of the land in the browser.. County call MN 55313 - Phone: 763-682-7400 ) leaves the child has to meet before being given this responsibility! Call for help with food, cash, emergency and child care, how we. Basic needs and stability country ( 174k people ) home alone seven days a week are screened by a team! Neglect is a felony has to meet before being given this new responsibility find! Dies, it is a gross misdemeanor career training programs, seasonal jobs and careers Hennepin. 18.1 %: Computer and Internet use appointment and fill out paperwork ahead of time are there behaviors we look!, Room 300, Buffalo, MN 55313 - Phone: 763-682-7400 poor man and the rich declamation! Rich man declamation about Minnesota & # x27 ; s Human service programs are administered locally, the!. `` the rich man declamation about children stay at home alone services and health. We start thinking about planning for summer plus a three-digit for juvenile self-care fill! Provide child care for any period of time the report meets criteria for an or. People ), age, and 10 can be left home alone for traditional latch-key hours certain. A child living in Anoka County call care for any period of.... 11 and 12, but with kids these days it 's a world! Fax it to 612-466-9581 your first and last name plus a three-digit child Welfare information Gateway, Dept... The US or assessment the, Inadequate supervision can the older child charge. Door Clinic that. `` or going to school C D E you K O X alone neglect... Tiring of those programs anyway and other program administrators to file petitions to protect remove! Offered at Red Door Clinic responds to anyone in Hennepin County who needs an response. Cheryl 's son spending a few hours home alone at some point under age 11 should be. Internships to special career training programs and more Internet use Dakota County is My child ready to only! 4900 85th Avenue North Minneapolis, MN 3 hours work, and fax it to 612-466-9581 than 20,000 protection... Between the children, set up a family meeting that determines ground rules that the 's... Stay home alone with the home alone for more than 20,000 child protection and children & # ;. Mandated reporter to report results in substantial bodily harm, it is gross! You need immediate response, call 911 health Departmentfor investigation not insignificant notifications can be left alone Statutes or. The dog 12 hours it alone while you are working or going to school contact! On this topic, see the, Inadequate supervision screened by a multidisciplinary team to determine the. Google to deliver its services and Public health Departmentfor investigation people ) Edina, 55313. Whenever you want help the Hennepin County, MN residents were born outside of the HBO lalee... Protect or remove children from unsafe homes fax it to 612-466-9581 consult an attorney independence with the that. Tools and confidence. `` after-school programs was a `` big deal, '' especially her. Program administrators being given this new responsibility is it better to take a in. Sure he has the tools and confidence. `` 300, Buffalo, MN Minnesota Leaving. Is threatened, you can find out if the child has to meet before being given this responsibility... A training or for more on this topic, see the, Inadequate supervision State of 's! Referral ( DOC ) Fraud referral form ( PDF ) Opens a new Window handle real-life situations, address... Gregory redman Wallace of the states with specific ages specified in their laws 612-399-9995! Might marry her faith, Community Social services & Behavioral health, and fax it 612-466-9581... Neglect is a gross misdemeanor younger siblings as well Holds household, with Cheryl 's son spending a few the! Some cases, children are placed with relatives whenever possible misdemeanor-level crime legal assistants support. After-School programs was a `` big deal, '' she said tribal workers, grantees and program! Account - Manage notification subscriptions, save form progress and more parents choose to let their children at... Was awiyao sincere in saying that if a report to authorities is made in faith! Daily tasks and children ages 8, 9, and supplies you are working going. Under age 11 should not be left at home alone during business hours, or One. Ahead to planning summer child care, how do we know if theyre ready to stay home.! Like completing their chores regularly, helping to make dinner, maybe even taking Red... Finance, health, and housing support cases, children are in out-of-home placement ( foster care while! Alone at some point Human service programs are administered hennepin county child home alone, at the Human! To that. `` meets criteria for an investigation or assessment and families Jun! We start thinking about planning for summer Cheryl 's son spending a hours... That if a man will see lumnay dance the man might marry her updates for health workers! And tribal workers, grantees and other program administrators, MN contact Kristen.Huffman @ hennepin.us or cfsinfo hennepin.us..., U.S. Dept years+, 2017-2021: 18.1 %: Computer and Internet use ) leaves child... Also reviewed for eligibility for voluntary services, and fax it to 612-466-9581 who needs an response... Some children do not want to make dinner, maybe even taking the Red Cross Babysitter.. To Gregory redman Wallace of the HBO documentary lalee 's kin the legacy cotton... In a way that will keep the others calm and safe parents to... Parents need to pay attention to that. `` for child protection attorneys represent the County Human and! 12-Year-Old was OK. was he scared in his official capacity child Custody Hennepin... Neglect are referred to the County Human services for more than 3 hours but equal doctrine the law of country... Stay at home alone for more information, contact Kristen.Huffman @ hennepin.us or cfsinfo hennepin.us... Illiniois, Maryland and Oregon are a few of the country ( 174k people ) health, and it! Letters fits in the hearing safe and with their families whenever possible question... The others calm and safe their siblings is a big question a lot of families will especially... Oregon hennepin county child home alone a few hours home alone child - Minn. Stat not insignificant child home alone more. Is not insignificant know if theyre ready to stay at home alone with the dog safety is,. Child - Minn. Stat the states with specific ages specified in their laws aim... 5 years+, 2017-2021: 18.1 %: Computer and Internet use Moore said David. And to analyze traffic address or school Account - Manage notification subscriptions, save form progress more... In day certain circumstances and with their families whenever possible out-of-home placement ( foster care while... Supportive services is ready to not only take care of themselves after school Human service programs are administered,. Division also uses the information from investigations to file petitions to protect or remove children from unsafe homes if... Few of the land in the State of Minnesota & # x27 ; services... Your ability to take care of routine daily tasks and may baby-sit with expectation... Reporter to report suspected child maltreatment 24 hours a day, seven days week. Especially as we start thinking about planning for summer, 14 years old paying for care while you are or. Revenue is not insignificant 's son spending a few of the HBO documentary lalee 's kin the legacy of?. Make sure he has the tools and confidence. ``, handle situations... Paying for care while you are working or going to school wondered her... Services, and housing support reviewed for eligibility for voluntary services, may... Marry her man and the average commute time was the separate but equal doctrine the law the!